“I’m not very good at making people like me.”
Why The Hunger Games’ Katniss Everdeen is one
of the most important heroes in modern culture.

Jennifer Lawrence as Katniss Everdeen

 

***SPOILER ALERT: Though there are no real spoilers here, one scene and the basic premise of the film are discussed in detail. If you’ve seen the preview for The Hunger Games, reading this review won’t reveal anything new, but if you haven’t seen the preview, I’d suggest you skip the part I’ve marked below.***

Possibly the most important moment in the film adaptation of The Hunger Games occurs when protagonist Katniss Everdeen (played with a perfect cross of vulnerability and strength by Kentucky native Jennifer Lawrence) confesses to her stylist Cinna (the circumspect Lenny Kravitz who aptly conveys the enormity of Katniss’ situation with his searing eyes) that she’s not very good at making people like her.

Katniss, after her arrival in the capital, with Cinna (played by Lenny Kravitz)

 

Katniss has just arrived in the capital to participate in the 74th Annual Hunger Games and is about to be interviewed on television by Caeser Flickerman (a blue-haired, ponytailed Stanley Tucci doing a slightly more likeable version of reality show host Ryan Seacrest). Her interview will be seen by absolutely everyone in Panem, the futuristic version of North America where this story takes place, so the stakes are high.

For this reason, Katniss is more than a little anxious.

SPOILER ALERT: SKIP THIS PARAGRAPH IF YOU HAVEN’T SEEN THE HUNGER GAMES PREVIEW . . . Adding to her anxiety is the fact that, just days before the interview takes place, Katniss volunteered to take her sister’s place when she was chosen by lot—calling to mind Shirley Jackson’s classic short story “The Lottery”—to represent their district in the Hunger Games that year.

Katniss' sister, Prim, at the reaping

 

The “Hunger Games” is a twisted, fight-to-the-death, televised competition—think William Golding’s Lord of the Flies and Richard Connell’s “The Most Dangerous Game” crossed with a reality show like Survivor—designed by Panam’s capital city to punish and intimidate the outlying districts of Panem for the uprising they orchestrated unsuccessfully against the capital 74 years before.

That risky political move ultimately led to the obliteration of one of the thirteen districts and the virtual enslavement of the other twelve districts (creating a world not totally unlike George Orwell’s 1984 or Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale). As a result, the people who live in the districts are now forced to live in such extreme poverty that dying of hunger is one of their greatest fears.

District 12 (formerly Appalachia)

 

Katniss isn’t just nervous because she’s about to appear on national television or enter an arena in which only one person will come out alive; she’s also apprensive because she knows that one of the ways a “tribute”—meaning a player in the Games—can get ahead is by making the people of the capital fall in love with her since they are allowed to sponsor tributes in the Games and send them gifts—medicine, water, weapons, anything—to help them win. So if she doesn’t make them like her, she could be sacrificing her own life in the process.

But Katniss feels that she isn’t the kind of person people like—she’s not warm or engaging, positive or open, nor is she particularly feminine (at least until her prep team in the capital puts her through a Twilight Zone-esque makeover process), yet these are the qualities that television audiences usually respond to. So when she is faced with the task of entertaining an entire country of viewers, she is terrified not just that they won’t like her, but that they’ll go so far as to root against her.

Katniss at the perimeter of District 12

 

This is a common fear for women in our society, especially young women who are expected to have cheerful personalities and sunny dispositions, who are supposed to be both people pleasers and objects of the male gaze. They are not supposed to be contemplative or cynical, as Katniss certainly is after having grown up in a society that forces her to kill squirrels on a daily basis to feed her fatherless family. So her fears about not being able to woo her television audience are not only valid, but also relatable.

If Katniss’ apprehensions about not being able to put on the right face for society are driven by her very real fear of dying in the arena, the fears of young women today are usually motivated by less sober concerns, but ones that surely feel just as profound when you’re sixteen years old.

Like Katniss, young women today worry about not being pretty enough or likeable enough, but they also worry about how their ability to do those things will ultimately affect their ability to find both happiness and success in life, a fate that may seem as serious as losing your life when you’re a teenager. So it’s no wonder this story appeals to young people—girls and boys alike. It speaks to their most overwhelming concerns: Will I be good enough? Will I be strong enough? Will people like me?

Ultimately Katniss is able to perform for the audience during her televised interview and win them over: not by being sunny or charismatic or entertaining—though she is forced to do the latter when she twirls in her designer ball gown, alighting the flames inside its skirt (an allusion to Katniss’ inner strength)—but by being herself, by being a real person with genuine thoughts and emotions, making her more honest and vulnerable than anyone else in the giant theatre full of costumed adults who congratulate and cheer for the tributes in a way that reveals their inability to understand the gravity of what they are doing to them.

Caeser Flickerman (played by Stanley Tucci) with Katniss at the conclusion of her televised interview

 

It’s a message repeated throughout the rest of her story and, more importantly, one we need to send more often to young people: Be yourself—not who other people expect you to be—and we will like you for who you are.

I cannot explain how much I appreciate Suzanne Collins for putting such an important message out in the world and for giving us the great gift of Katniss Everdeen, one of the most admirable and honest young heroes ever committed to the page or screen. And I hope you will appreciate her as much as I do.

5 comments

  1. Diana says:

    I appreciate your perspective on Katniss and I agree with your point that not every woman should have to be “both people pleasers and objects of the male gaze.” But I think there are a lot of problems with Katniss’ character and I’m honestly pretty disappointed in the way Collins develops (or rather doesn’t develop) her character.

    *Spoiler alert*
    Collins had an opportunity to create a strong female character who embraces her life, even if she doesn’t like it. But what happens instead is that Katniss becomes a passive character who is controlled by those around her to the point where she has a breakdown. She never makes a responsible decision or contributes anything more meaningful than a pretty face to the rebel’s cause. She’s pathetic, and in the end, she’s married with kids. What does that say about women?

  2. […] you’re here for Tuesday’s post, please see my review of The Hunger Games below. I got excited and couldn’t wait until today to post it, so it went up Saturday […]

  3. […] McCaffrey believes Katniss is “one of the most important heroes in modern culture” as Hunger Games raises the pervasive issue of female likeability. Because she’s sullen and not […]

  4. […] McCaffrey believes Katniss is “one of the most important heroes in modern culture” as Hunger Games raises the pervasive issue of female likeability. Because she’s sullen and not […]

  5. Mormonhippie says:

    The problem with Katniss, at least to me it seems, is that after the first Hunger Games book her character seemed to be influenced by another popular female heroine in literature: Bella Swan.
    For Katniss to change so suddenly from a fierce, strong, virtuous character to a passive pawn was very out of character.

    (Spoiler ALERT AHEAD >>> while I have absolutely no objection to a woman getting married and having children…in fact I think there is no higher calling in life…it did not feel to me that this was done on Katniss’ terms. In the resolution of the story it felt more like something she did…passively.)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • twitterfacebook